WhatNext TV recommendations

Shows Like American Horror Story

If American Horror Story worked for you because of its big ideas, mystery, and long-form payoff, start with Carrie, Grimm, and Tale of the Nine Tailed. The list leans toward mystery and drama stories with a similar sense of concept-heavy storytelling. It prioritises shared tone and story shape rather than relying on broad genre matching alone.

See the matches Search another show

24 recommendationsStart with Carrie, Grimm, Tale of the Nine Tailed

Recommendations tuned for fans of American Horror Story

Audience fit

Why American Horror Story fans may like these shows

If you enjoyed American Horror Story, try Carrie, Grimm, and Tale of the Nine Tailed. These recommendations focus on mystery and drama shows that share mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a similar storytelling rhythm.

Ranked recommendations

The closest TV shows to watch after American Horror Story

Each recommendation includes the reasoning behind the pick, so you can see why it may suit fans of American Horror Story.

Carrie

Carrie is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Mystery, Drama, and Sci-Fi & Fantasy Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, After her father's sudden, untimely death thrusts her into the unforgiving ecosystem of public high school, Carrie is forced to navigate a viral bullying scandal that tears through her community, the relentless…

Grimm

Grimm is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Drama, Mystery, and Sci-Fi & Fantasy Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, After Portland homicide detective Nick Burkhardt discovers he's descended from an elite line of criminal profilers known as "Grimms," he increasingly finds his responsibilities as a detective at odds with his new…

Tale of the Nine Tailed

Tale of the Nine Tailed is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Drama, and Mystery Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, A TV producer discovers a secret supernatural world as she becomes entangled with a former deity who's spent centuries searching for his lost lover.

FROM

FROM is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Mystery, Drama, and Sci-Fi & Fantasy Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, Unravel the mystery of a nightmarish town in middle America that traps all those who enter. As the unwilling residents fight to keep a sense of normalcy and search for a way out, they must also survive the threats of…

Supernatural

Supernatural is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Drama, Mystery, and Sci-Fi & Fantasy Recommendation graph signal: this title appears close to the anchor show in recommendation data. In practical terms, When they were boys, Sam and Dean Winchester lost their mother to a mysterious and demonic supernatural force. Subsequently, their father raised them to be soldiers. He taught them about the paranormal evil that lives…

Stranger Things

Stranger Things is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Mystery and Sci-Fi & Fantasy Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, When a young boy vanishes, a small town uncovers a mystery involving secret experiments, terrifying supernatural forces, and one strange little girl.

Fringe

Fringe is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Drama, and Mystery Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, FBI Special Agent Olivia Dunham, brilliant but formerly institutionalized scientist Walter Bishop and his scheming, reluctant son Peter uncover a deadly mystery involving a series of unbelievable events and realize…

IT: Welcome to Derry

IT: Welcome to Derry is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Drama and Mystery Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, In 1962, amid a spate of unexplained disappearances of local children, a group of misfit friends begin to suspect a long-buried ancient evil lurking. As the kids set out to determine what's really going on, a rising…

The Haunting of Hill House

The Haunting of Hill House is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Mystery and Drama Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, Flashing between past and present, a fractured family confronts haunting memories of their old home and the terrifying events that drove them from it.

Widow's Bay

Widow's Bay is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Drama and Mystery Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, The mayor of a New England town resolves to turn it into the next tourist hot spot, despite local warnings that it's cursed.

American Horror Stories

American Horror Stories is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Drama, Mystery, and Sci-Fi & Fantasy Recommendation graph signal: this title appears close to the anchor show in recommendation data. In practical terms, An anthology series of stand alone episodes delving into horror myths, legends and lore.

Lovecraft Country

Lovecraft Country is a strong follow-up to American Horror Story because it offers mystery, world-building and payoff over time and a comparable sense of concept-heavy storytelling. Shared genre fit: Drama, Mystery, and Sci-Fi & Fantasy Story-shape signal: this title was selected because its themes and tone are a close fit. In practical terms, The anthology horror series follows 25-year-old Atticus Freeman, who joins up with his friend Letitia and his Uncle George to embark on a road trip across 1950s Jim Crow America to find his missing father. They must…

What makes a good show like American Horror Story?

A good replacement for American Horror Story is not just another show in the same broad genre. The best matches keep the parts viewers remember most: big ideas, mystery, and long-form payoff, a atmospheric atmosphere and concept-heavy storytelling. That is why the ranking combines several signals before a title reaches the final list.

How these recommendations are chosen

Audience behaviour: Reddit-style co-mentions and pair signals help identify shows viewers naturally compare or recommend together. Recommendation graph: TMDB recommendation data helps identify titles that sit close to the anchor show. Story fit: genre overlap, semantic keywords and concept-specific guardrails reduce lazy matches that share only a surface-level category. Quality control: vote average, vote count, popularity and freshness checks help remove weak or low-confidence titles from public SEO pages.

Editor's verdict

The strongest starting point is Carrie, Grimm, and Tale of the Nine Tailed because the list balances similarity, quality and viewer behaviour. For best results, choose the recommendation that matches the part of American Horror Story you liked most: tone, characters, setting, mystery, tension or long-form payoff.

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

Which shows scratch the same itch as American Horror Story?

These are not just similar on genre. They were chosen because they offer a related mix of mystery, world-building and long-form payoff for viewers who connected with American Horror Story.

What should I watch after American Horror Story for more big-idea storytelling?

Carrie, Grimm, and Tale of the Nine Tailed are a good place to start if you want another series that unfolds gradually and rewards attention over time.

Are these recommendations more about mood or plot?

Usually both. The strongest matches tend to share atmosphere as well as structure, so the page does not just chase shows with similar premises.

How do I find more shows once I finish these?

Build up your favourites and ratings in WhatNext and the app can keep narrowing in on the sci-fi and fantasy shows that suit your taste best.

Keep exploring

Explore more recommendations

Shows like Carrie Shows like Grimm Shows like Tale of the Nine Tailed Shows like FROM Shows like Supernatural Shows like Stranger Things Shows like Fringe Shows like IT: Welcome to Derry Shows like The Haunting of Hill House Shows like Widow's Bay

Create an account to save favourites and get personalised recommendations